Skip to main content
On this page

Uber and the Ethics of Sharing: Exploring the Societal Promises and Responsibilities of the Sharing Economy - Case Solution

Craig N Smith and Erin McCormick | Harvard Business Review ( IN1344-PDF-ENG ) | May 29, 2017 (Revision: 2023-09-09)
Abstract:

This "Uber and the Ethics of Sharing" case study focuses on the implications of the "sharing economy" business models, specifically Uber, and questions the responsibility of companies involved in this market. It examines whether these companies are merely platforms for private individuals or if they should have the same responsibilities as other companies.

Case Questions Answered

  • Create a Business Model Canvas for Uber and understand the value creation process.
  • Who are the winners, and who are the losers from the introduction of Uber?
  • Why is it important for Uber to be considered a "technology platform" and not a "transportation company?" What would the implications be if Uber were a "transportation company?"
  • What are the implications of business models like Uber's on the future of employment? Do "sharing economy" companies have a responsibility to protect their workers (or contractors?)

1.) Create a Business Model Canvas for Uber and understand the value

creation process.

Uber and the Ethics of Sharing - Exploring the Societal Promises and Responsibilities of the Sharing EconomyBusiness Model Canvas

2.) Who are the winners, and who are the losers from the introduction of

Uber?

The winners are:

The Uber Company

Uber Corporation receives 20% of the charge fees paid by the drivers. Aside from that, they make more profit when the app grows in popularity.

Uber, a sharing economy firm, considers the driver-partners as independent contractors. Thus, the company incurs savings by not offering employment benefits & social security schemes.

Uber does not invest in a fleet of cars. Instead, the company invests in software that connects drivers and passengers, which is highly scalable and has a considerably more significant profit margin.

The Uber Passengers

Passengers can travel quickly and conveniently by searching for an Uber ride near them. The passenger also benefits from the payment scheme.

Before getting into the car, the passenger knows the transportation costs.

Passengers do not have to wait alongside the road, which exposes them to danger.

Also, they don’t have to bargain with local drivers because they can use Uber and sit inside to see the car on their phones.

The Uber Drivers

Uber’s drivers are self-employed individuals who use their app version to receive and respond to calls to be picked up and paid.

The drivers also benefit from the payment scheme. Uber drivers are exempt from regulations and do not pay the same high taxes as traditional taxi drivers.

The losers are:

Preview Only — Unlock Full Content Below

Complete Case Solution

Get immediate access to the full, detailed analysis

  • Comprehensive answers to all case questions
  • Detailed analysis with supporting evidence
  • Instant digital delivery (PDF format)
Buy Full Case Solution

Secure payment • Instant access

By clicking, you agree to our Terms of Use, Arbitration and Class Action Waiver Agreement and Privacy Policy